Introvert or Extrovert?


Horses have different personalities, just as humans do. And the personality dictates how you handle and train if you want to have a successful collaboration with your horse. Today I’m partially recycling a post from two years ago when I first started blogging. I assume most of my current readers haven’t seen it before. 

Extrovert enjoying showing off

Extrovert enjoying showing off

You can classify horses as having one of four basic personalities. (Of course, there are other ways to categorize them, but this one works for me.) Just like with people, they can be Extroverts or Introverts. They also can be Thinkers or Reactors (emotional). So you can have an extroverted thinker, an extroverted reactor, an introverted thinker and an introverted reactor. Then you add their gender and their experience into the equation and you have a complicated being that requires some thought to train effectively. Each personality type has its pluses and minuses and is good for different things and different riders. And each type needs to be dealt with in different ways.

Star, the little Morgan mare I grew up with, was an extroverted thinker. She was friendly, self-confident, rarely afraid of anything and willing to try whatever I asked her. She was also strong-willed and could be difficult. Once we started communicating properly she was easy to teach. Correct, fair treatment was key with her. She couldn’t be forced, but would give her all when asked. She loved to learn new skills, do different things and explore new trails. She really enjoyed life.

Horses are prey animals and, as such, are basically “scaredy cats.” In the wild they stay alive by being hyper-aware of their environment and ready to run on an instant. Domestication hasn’t done away with that basic instinct. A horse whose emotions dominate sees threats everywhere and can react without thinking. My Portia was a prime example. When I first got her, she would whirl and try to bolt at the slightest provocation. Typical extroverted reactor. She needed very calm, relaxed handling. If she got upset I loosened the reins. Trying to fight with her would have brought on an explosion.

Glory, on the other hand, is a super-sensitive Thoroughbred who requires somewhat different handling because of her introverted reactor personality. She was basically timid, afraid of the world, and over-reacted to stimuli when I first got her.

Thinker, working hard

Thinker, working hard

Due to inappropriate handling she learned to shut down under saddle and would only respond if she was cued in exactly the way she had been trained. She was afraid to try. At the same time she was a panic attack waiting to happen on the ground. The slightest thing would provoke a frantic pull-back. My job was to convince her she was safe.

My husband’s horse, Koko, could have been the poster child for the introverted thinker type. Strong-willed and stubborn, she often had to be convinced to do what we wanted. Thank goodness she was also laid-back, sensible and good-natured. Her busy mind was evidenced by her quirky sense of humor and love of playing. She delighted in doing things like untying ropes (just to show she could) and flipping the barn light switches on and off.

What kind of equine personalities have you dealt with? What kind do you enjoy?

Categories: animals, horse care, horse personalities, Horses, nature, riding, Thoroughbreds, training horses, Uncategorized | Tags: , , , , , , | 7 Comments

Post navigation

7 thoughts on “Introvert or Extrovert?

  1. Thanks for the post…

  2. Good topic, Kate. I didn’t get my first horse until I was 38, and between my kids and I, we had close to a dozen horses and I currently have downsized to two ponies, They all had different personalities. Some were very docile and well behaved and some wanted their own way. My ponies are sisters – a year apart, and the younger one is definitely the one who is more demanding and pushy. Also, more likely to go after someone or something that comes into the pasture.

    I think different personalities are true of all animals. I love collies and over the years have had a lot of them. While a lot of their personalities are similar; loving, friendly, herding instincts, etc. they are still not the same. My current collie, Maggie, is different in many ways from the one I had to put down four years ago. Molly was very outgoing and eager to meet new situation. She herded the chickens or grandchildren when we walked in the woods. Maggie is much more timid. She will not approach new people of other dogs until I show they are friendly, and she never herds anything. Although after almost four years she’s grown accustomed to my two sister house cats, one of them who used to act aggressive, still makes her nervous. If the chickens get out, she just looks at them.

    • Thanks for stopping by Gloria. It is fun to see how different each animal can be. And how much the personality, not the size, determines their order in the herd. I’ve seen a small Shetland rule a herd of full-sized horses and a big gelding hide in the corner.

      The smartest dog I ever had was a Border Collie mix. She’d herd anything and was very protective. Even took on a Great Dane twice her size when she thought he was scaring my toddler son.

  3. Greta

    Great post, Kate!

  4. marsharwest

    Fascinating post, Kate. Don’t have horses, but I can see how this personality thing works. I’ve seen similar things with pups. And the A dog, regardless of size rules. It’s pretty funny. I’ll share.

    • Glad you enjoyed it Marsha. Personality may not be as important with smaller animals, such as sheep, geese or chickens, but definitely needs to be taken into account with potentially dangerous animals you work with. Dogs fit in this category too. Makes sense to keeps things easy and safe.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: